Contesting an Indiana Last Will and Testament

When you contest a Will in Indiana, you ask a probate court to determine that the document admitted to probate is not legally valid. This action is more than an expression of disappointment about the way property was distributed. You are initiating formal litigation that challenges whether the instrument truly reflects the decedent’s lawful intent. A Will contest proceeds within the probate case and follows procedures similar to other civil lawsuits, including pleadings, evidence gathering, witness testimony, and judicial determination. Because a Will controls the transfer of a person’s property at death, Indiana courts require strict compliance with statutory standards for the document to be valid. If those standards were not satisfied when the document was executed, you may have grounds to seek invalidation. Before pursuing such a claim, however, you must understand what Indiana law requires, who may file a challenge, and what legal theories support setting a Will aside. With that in mind, the Indianapolis lawyers at Frank & Kraft discuss contesting an Indiana Last Will and Testament.

Legal Standards for a Valid Will in Indiana

For a Will to be enforceable in Indiana, several elements must exist at the time of signing. The person creating the Will, referred to as the testator, must be at least eighteen years old. Age alone is insufficient. The testator must also possess testamentary capacity. This means you must be able to demonstrate that the testator understood the nature of making a Will, recognized the general extent of his or her property, and knew the natural objects of his or her bounty, such as close family members.

The document must be in writing. Indiana does not recognize purely oral Wills in most circumstances. The testator must sign the Will, or another person may sign on the testator’s behalf in the testator’s presence and at the testator’s direction. Two competent witnesses must also sign the document. These witnesses typically observe the testator sign or acknowledge the signature. Failure to comply with these formalities can undermine the validity of the instrument.

If you discover that one or more of these requirements was not satisfied, you may have a basis to bring a contest. Courts examine compliance carefully because formal execution requirements are designed to prevent fraud and ensure authenticity.

Who May File a Will Contest in Indiana?

You cannot challenge a Will simply because you disagree with its contents. Indiana law requires that you have standing, meaning a legally recognized interest in the estate. Standing generally belongs to individuals who would be affected financially if the Will were declared invalid.

You may qualify as an interested person if you are a legal heir under Indiana’s intestate succession statutes. For example, a surviving spouse or child who would inherit if no valid Will existed may possess standing. You may also have standing if you were named in an earlier Will and received a larger gift than you did under the current document. Creditors of the estate can sometimes participate if their financial interests are implicated. The purpose of this limitation is to prevent unrelated individuals from interfering in probate proceedings. The court will dismiss a contest if you cannot demonstrate a direct economic stake in the outcome.

Strict Filing Deadline

Indiana imposes a firm time limit for bringing a Will contest. You must file your petition within three months after the Will is admitted to probate. This period begins when the court officially accepts the Will and opens the estate administration. If you miss this deadline, your opportunity to challenge the document is typically lost. Courts enforce this timeframe rigorously to promote finality and efficient estate settlement. If you suspect irregularities, prompt consultation with counsel is essential.

Recognized Grounds for Challenging a Will

Dissatisfaction with the distribution scheme in a Last Will and Testament is not sufficient to pursue a Will contest. You must allege and prove specific legal grounds recognized under Indiana law, including:

• Lack of Testamentary Capacity: If you can show that the testator did not understand the nature of the act of making a Will or could not comprehend the extent of property or the identity of heirs at the time of signing, the court may declare the document invalid. Medical records, testimony from treating physicians, and observations from family members or caregivers often become central evidence.
• Undue Influence: This occurs when someone exerts such pressure on the testator that the resulting document reflects the influencer’s desires rather than the testator’s independent intent. You may see this claim arise when a caregiver, relative, or new acquaintance isolates the testator and receives a disproportionately large share of the estate. The court examines the relationship between the parties, the testator’s vulnerability, and the circumstances surrounding execution.
• Fraud/Forgery: Fraud may involve misleading the testator about the nature of the document being signed. Forgery involves falsifying a signature or fabricating the instrument entirely. If you can establish that the document is not authentic, the court will refuse to enforce it.
• Improper Execution: If the Will lacks the required witness signatures, if the signing process did not meet statutory requirements, or if the document was not properly executed, the court may find it defective.
• Subsequent Will: If you locate a more recent document that revokes or contradicts the admitted Will and satisfies Indiana’s execution requirements, the newer instrument may control distribution.

Elective Share Rights of a Surviving Spouse

If you are a surviving spouse, Indiana law grants you a measure of statutory protection. Rather than contesting the Will directly, you may elect to take a statutory share in lieu of what the document provides. This elective share currently guarantees a minimum amount, even if the Will attempts to disinherit you or leave you a nominal gift. The elective share does not automatically invalidate the Will. Instead, it modifies distribution to ensure that you receive the statutory minimum. This option can provide a practical solution in some cases, avoiding the expense and uncertainty of litigation.

Understanding No Contest Clauses

Many Wills contain a provision commonly known as a no contest clause, sometimes referred to as an in terrorem clause. This language states that if a beneficiary challenges the Will and fails, that beneficiary forfeits all or part of the inheritance provided under the document. The purpose of this clause is to discourage litigation and protect the testator’s distribution scheme from disruptive disputes. If you are considering a challenge and the Will includes such a clause, you must evaluate the potential risk carefully.

Enforcement of No Contest Clauses in Indiana

Indiana generally recognizes the validity of no contest clauses, but enforcement is not automatic. Courts examine several factors before imposing the stated penalty. The clause must clearly specify the consequences of initiating a challenge. Ambiguous provisions may be construed narrowly or deemed unenforceable. Indiana courts also consider whether you had reasonable grounds for bringing the contest. If you can demonstrate that your challenge was supported by credible evidence of incapacity, undue influence, fraud, or another recognized basis, the court may decline to enforce the forfeiture. This principle protects beneficiaries who act with legitimate concerns rather than malicious intent. Good faith also plays a significant role. If your claim is brought sincerely and grounded in fact, the court may exercise discretion in determining whether the penalty should apply. Frivolous or vexatious litigation is more likely to trigger enforcement of the clause. Finally, public policy considerations also influence judicial decisions. If enforcing the clause would produce an inequitable result or shield serious misconduct from scrutiny, the court may refuse to apply the forfeiture provision.

Do You Have Additional Questions about Contesting an Indiana Will?

For more information, please join us for an upcoming FREE seminar. If you have additional questions or concerns about contesting an Indiana Will, contact the experienced Indianapolis probate lawyers at Frank & Kraft by calling (317) 684-1100 to schedule an appointment.

The post Contesting an Indiana Last Will and Testament appeared first on Frank & Kraft, Attorneys at Law.